Skip to content

Is your persona any good? Five questions to check it

A five-question check for any persona, yours or someone else's, with a weak example to practice on, a way to score it and what to fix first.

Most personas are never reviewed. They get made, they look finished, and looking finished gets taken as proof of being right. This guide is a check you can run on any persona in five minutes, whether you made it, inherited it or are grading it. Five questions, a weak example to practice on, and what to do with the answers.

The persona everyone has seen

Here is a persona of the kind that fills portfolios and kickoff decks:

Sarah, 28, marketing manager. Lives in the city. Loves coffee, yoga and travel. Tech-savvy and always busy. Goal: a seamless experience. Frustration: apps that are slow and confusing. Quote: "I just want things to work."

Nothing in it is false. That is the problem: nothing in it could be false. Keep Sarah in mind, because each question below takes something away from her.

1. Is there a quote a person would say?

Read the quote out loud. Real speech has contractions, a hedge, and a noun that belongs to one job or one kitchen. "I just want things to work" is a slogan. It fits every product ever made, so it tells you nothing about this one.

Compare it with the quote on the persona further down this page: "Show me the money and the miles before I accept. Everything else can wait until I'm parked." It names things. It has a setting. You could design a screen from it.

Pass: the quote names a specific thing, place or moment, and you know who said it. Fail: it would fit on a billboard.

2. Does it say what it is based on?

Look at the bottom of the page. A persona should end with a line that says where it came from: which interviews, how many, when. Our guide to research-based personas covers why that line matters more than any other.

This question is about honesty, not rigor. "Team assumptions from the March kickoff, not yet tested" passes. So does "Illustrative composite, not a research persona." What fails is silence, or the word "research" with nothing after it.

Pass: a source and a date, even when the source is a guess. Fail: no line at all. Sarah has none.

3. Could this be anyone?

Try two swaps. First, change the name, the age and the photo. Does anything else on the page have to change? Second, move the persona to a different product. Would Sarah work just as well for a banking app, a grocery app and a project tracker? She would, which means she describes none of them.

Then look for one detail nobody would invent. A driver who tracks earnings in a paper notebook because he does not trust the app's summary. A schedule taped inside a cabinet door. Details like these come from being in the room, and they are the first thing to go missing when a persona is written from a desk.

Pass: at least one detail that surprised the team. Fail: the page survives both swaps.

4. Would it change a decision?

Take each goal and frustration and ask: "So what would we build differently?" "A seamless experience" changes nothing, because nobody is building for the opposite. "Decide on a trip in two seconds from pay, distance and direction" settles what goes on a screen, in what order and at what size.

A persona earns its place when someone can point at a line to end an argument. How to use personas in design has six ways to do that.

Pass: three or more lines you could cite in a design review. Fail: every line is something any user of any product would agree with.

5. Is it a segment in disguise?

A segment says who people are: age, job title, income, hobbies. A persona says what one person is trying to do and what gets in the way. Segments are useful for deciding who to reach. They do not tell you what to build.

Cover the facts at the top of the page with your hand. If what is left still describes a person in a situation, you have a persona. With Sarah, cover the age, the job and the hobbies and almost nothing is left.

Pass: the page still works with the demographics hidden. Fail: the demographics are the page.

Example personaOpen on its own page
Avatar for Tesfaye Alemu

Tesfaye Alemu

Full-time rideshare and delivery driver

“Show me the money and the miles before I accept. Everything else can wait until I'm parked.”
Age
36
Location
Washington, D.C.
Occupation
Driver, 50 to 60 hours a week
Education
Bachelor's, civil engineering (Addis Ababa)

Summary

Tesfaye drives six days a week with two apps open on a phone mounted to the dash. He tracks earnings per hour in a notebook because he does not trust the apps' summaries, and he has learned which neighborhoods and hours pay. He is fluent in three languages and reads English fast, but at 30 miles an hour he reads numbers, not sentences.

Goals

  • Decide on a trip in two seconds from pay, distance and direction
  • See the week's real earnings after gas and fees
  • Dispute a wrong fare or a bad rating without a chat bot

Frustrations

  • Promotions with conditions buried three screens deep
  • App updates that change the accept button while he is on shift
  • Support replies that restate the policy instead of fixing the trip

Scenarios

  • A ride request appears at a red light; he has to read it and decide before the light changes
  • A rider leaves a bag in the car; he needs to return it and get paid for the trip back
  • Tax season: he needs mileage by month in a file his accountant can open

Comfort with technology

Based on

Illustrative composite. Drawn from published gig-work surveys and driver forums. Not a research persona: no drivers were interviewed for this profile.

Made with Persona Generator

Running the check on one of ours

Tesfaye Alemu, above, is from our example gallery. Here is how he does.

  1. Quote: half a pass. It sounds like speech and it names things. But read his "Based on" section: no drivers were interviewed, so nobody said it.
  2. Based on: pass. It says plainly that he is an illustrative composite drawn from surveys and forums.
  3. Could be anyone: pass. The notebook and the two apps on the dash do not transfer to another product.
  4. Changes a decision: pass. The two-second goal and the red-light scenario both tell you what a ride request has to look like.
  5. Segment: pass. Cover his age and city and he is still a driver deciding at a red light.

So Tesfaye is a well-formed persona that a team should not bet on yet. That is the kind of answer the check is for. It does not sort personas into good and bad. It tells you how much weight a page can bear, and what is missing.

What the score tells you

Passes What you have What to do next
0 or 1 A template with a name on it Start again from the people you can talk to
2 or 3 A proto-persona Label it as assumptions and turn each failed question into an interview question
4 A usable persona with one gap Fix the gap before the next review
5 A persona you can defend Date it, and run the check again when the product or the audience changes

Sarah scores zero. She cannot be edited into a better persona, because the missing material is not on the page or in anyone's head. It is in conversations that have not happened yet. Three to five interviews with people of one type is enough to rebuild her, and our interview questions guide has a script for them.

Reviewing someone else's persona

If you are a teacher, a lead or a teammate, ask the five questions as questions. "Where did this quote come from?" gets a better second draft than "this quote is weak." Most weak personas come from a template that asked for an age and three hobbies, and the person who filled it in did what they were asked.

Start with question 2. Once the "Based on" line is honest, the other four answers usually follow from it, and the author can see for themselves what to go and find out.

Check yours

Open your persona, or make one, and run the five questions before anyone else does. If the answers send you back to do interviews and you do not have the time, that is the work Mobility Labs does: we talk to your users and hand back personas that pass all five.

Make a persona with what you learned

Free, no sign-up. Pick a persona type and start typing.

Make a persona

Base your personas on real research

Mobility Labs runs user research: interviews, surveys and usability tests. We can run yours.

See how we run user research